The iconic Island Bay Lighthouse, one of Wellington’s most popular Airbnbs, is back on the market two years after it last changed hands.

For hundreds of guests, the three-level structure has offered the chance to fulfil a lifelong fantasy of staying in a lighthouse, even if it was never actually used as one.

Wellington couple Nicola Patrick and Jason Quinn bought the one-bedroom property for $735,000 in April 2024, initially intending to transform the site into their forever home.

“We just fell in love with this part of the South Coast and the amazing views. Having it as a mini business as the Airbnb wasn't a huge priority for us, but, funnily enough, it's turned out to be a real buzz,” Patrick told OneRoof.

Start your property search

Find your dream home today.
Search

The couple had hoped to retain the lighthouse while building a four-bedroom family home alongside it. Quinn specialises in passive homes, and the couple planned to create their own energy-efficient dream house.

But after exploring their options, they realised the 566sqm site simply wasn't big enough.

The Island Bay Lighthouse, on the South Coast, is one of Wellington's most popular Aibnbs. Photo / Supplied

The Island Bay Lighthouse has incredible views over the beach and out to the ocean. Photo / Supplied

The Island Bay Lighthouse, on the South Coast, is one of Wellington's most popular Aibnbs. Photo / Supplied

Overseas visitors loved booking the Airbnb and fulfilling their dreams of staying in a lighthouse. Photo / Supplied

“We hoped that we'd be able to retain the lighthouse and sort of build around it. And then we went through the thought process of, ‘Oh my God, it's not going to work. We're going to have to demolish it. We're going to be the awful people who demolish this iconic building.'"

The prospect of tearing down the much-loved landmark never sat comfortably with them. Instead, they developed plans to replace it with a slightly larger lighthouse-inspired structure and secured resource consent for a five-level family home.

The approved concept design includes four bedrooms, two bathrooms, a study and a lift, with plans available to the new owner.

“Because of the nature of the site, we wanted to just go up. So, it sounds a bit weird when you call it a five-storey house, because it's really more like two-and-a-half storeys,” Patrick said, adding that the first two levels were for the lift entrance and storage.

Discover more:

- House prices down 32% - but Wellington’s mansions are making a play for history

- Historic mansion could smash Sir Rod Drury’s house price record

- All Blacks legend selling his Coromandel escape

After two years of planning, however, the couple faced a reality check.

“We've got three teenage boys, and eventually they are going to start leaving home, and we just decided we'd rather head more down the downsize route than the build dream home route.”

They have since bought another property in Island Bay, just minutes from the lighthouse and still within sight of it.

Patrick said selling was ultimately the sensible choice.

“We're just trying to be sensible, and also pass it on. Like, someone else can take forward our dream, and we might just be a bit sad about that.”

What started as a side venture has become one of Wellington's standout short-term accommodation businesses.

The Island Bay Lighthouse was booked for 276 nights in the last calendar year alone, excluding dates reserved by the owners and their friends. Around 70% of guests travelled from overseas.

Nightly rates start at about $282, excluding Airbnb and cleaning fees.

“It really is very popular. It's super popular with overseas honeymooners, which means they stay weekdays,” Patrick said. The weekends were often filled up with locals wanting a unique escape.

“We get so many amazing reviews. People just write the most gushing, beautiful comments, and they're so thankful they got this chance to live their dream of staying in a lighthouse, even though it never actually was a lighthouse.”

The Island Bay Lighthouse, on the South Coast, is one of Wellington's most popular Aibnbs. Photo / Supplied

The one-bedroom lighthouse on The Esplanade, in Island Bay, Wellington, has never shone a light. Photo / Supplied

While the building looks every bit the part, complete with a beacon salvaged from a decommissioned Christchurch lighthouse and a narrow staircase winding through its three levels, it was never a working lighthouse.

Instead, it was originally built as a creative retreat for an artist.

Patrick said it was easy to forget that detail while gazing across Cook Strait.

“It feels like a lighthouse, and it feels so private, and it feels so rugged and isolated, and the views are incredible. So, we've had this amazing experience of sharing it with other people, which has brought us so much joy.”

And then there are the views. “Honestly, when you're sitting up on the top floor, you can't beat it. You see all the boats on the horizon, you see the planes landing, you see dolphins, you see orcas. I mean, you just don't get bored."

Tommy's agent David Vaughan, who sold the property to the couple in 2024, told OneRoof the property's appeal extended well beyond its novelty factor. “The Lighthouse was already a good business, but the current owners have turned it into a great business.”

Vaughan said buyers had several options: continue operating the successful Airbnb, use the existing resource consent and concept plans to build a substantial family home, or simply enjoy the property as a private seaside retreat.

The property has an RV of $690,000.

- 326 The Esplanade, Island Bay, Wellington, is for sale, tender closing December 2