Homes in Auckland’s blue-chip St Marys Bay routinely change hands for several million dollars, but what could be the suburb’s sharpest bargain has emerged: a renovated two-level villa with harbour views.

The property at 14 Harbour Street has an RV of $2.295 million, pre-renovation, but an asking price of $1.999m.

Ray White listing agent Dylan Tracey told OneRoof the three-bedroom, two-bathroom home represented some of the best value currently available in the tightly held inner-city suburb.

Tracey said the 1925 house was bought last year for $1.5m by a professional property renovator, who then undertook an extensive makeover.

Start your property search

Find your dream home today.
Search

The vendor first brought the property to market in June but struggled to attract buyers at the level he was hoping for. Rather than wait for market conditions to improve, he decided to sharpen the price and move on to other projects.

“I guess the price is really speaking to how motivated the owner is,” Tracey said.

“He’s obviously spent a lot of money on it, and he’s coming out the other side just saying, ‘Look, I’m ready to move on rather than try and hang out’.”

14 Harbour Street, in St Marys Bay, Auckland, first hit the market in June, but interest has spiked since it was given a price. Photo / Supplied

14 Harbour Street boasts views across Westhaven Marina, the Waitematā Harbour, and the Auckland Harbour Bridge. Photo / Supplied

14 Harbour Street, in St Marys Bay, Auckland, first hit the market in June, but interest has spiked since it was given a price. Photo / Supplied

The vendor, a professional trader, bought the property a year ago for $1.5m and transformed it. Photo / Supplied

14 Harbour Street, in St Marys Bay, Auckland, first hit the market in June, but interest has spiked since it was given a price. Photo / Supplied

The house has benefitted from a new kitchen, bathroom and decking. Photo / Supplied

The pricing strategy appears to be working, with buyer interest surging since the asking price was revealed.

“A recurring comment is that buyers didn’t think they could find a home in St Marys Bay or near Ponsonby for under $2m, especially one that isn’t a do-up.”

Tracey said the house was “very, very tired” when the vendor bought it, with the renovation including a new kitchen, bathrooms, flooring, roof and deck.

“It feels like it’s just ready to be enjoyed and it’s presented well – the view is just spectacular.”

Marketed as a low-maintenance lock-up-and-leave home, the property is attracting interest from both Auckland and out-of-town buyers.

Discover more:

- 'Oh my goodness': Grammar zone homes selling for hundreds of thousands less

- Buyers rush to view $4m-plus villa once owned by NZ's most colourful mayor

- Phone bidders from China hang up, then buy: Paritai Drive bowler sells for $3.7m

Tracey said a couple from Queenstown were flying north to inspect it, while other prospective purchasers were looking for a city base that would allow them to spend more time at holiday homes in Omaha or Piha.

He said St Marys Bay’s low turnover and tightly held nature meant opportunities below $2m were increasingly rare.

While one-bedroom apartments can still be found in the $500,000 to $600,000 range, larger family homes typically command $4m-plus.

A renovated family home below the $2m mark is almost unheard of.

14 Harbour Street, in St Marys Bay, Auckland, first hit the market in June, but interest has spiked since it was given a price. Photo / Supplied

A five-bedroom villa for sale at 64 St Marys Road, in St Marys Bay, has an RV of over $6m. Photo / Supplied

“To have a renovated house for under $2m, three-bed, two-bath, with a garage – internal access – is extremely rare, and then you’re getting a view chucked in as well," Tracey said.

“I mean, $2m is almost a do-up price in some regards, so you’ve got it done up with a view.”

Potential buyers Tracey showed through told him this week: “I can never get sick of that view.”

OneRoof records show just seven homes in St Marys Bay have sold for under $2m since 2023. One of the most recent was the sale of the four-bedroom home on Yarborough Street, which changed hands for $1.9m in May this year.

At the other end of the spectrum, New Zealand Sotheby’s International Realty has a five-bedroom, four-bathroom St Marys Bay renovated villa for sale with an RV of over $6m.

- 14 Harbour Street, St Marys Bay, Auckland, is for sale for $1.999m